Arisaig Partners

Pricing carbon into company valuations

At Arisaig, we believe that Purposeful Growth companies – those that think about overall value creation across multiple stakeholders, including customers, employees, local communities, and the environment – tend to deliver superior long-term shareholder returns. At first glance, this seems to be at odds with the views of Milton Friedman, who is often characterized as being anti-stakeholder in his stance on shareholder primacy. However, this only holds if the value creation process of a company is entirely disconnected from its impact on stakeholders. The evidence suggests that since his famous ‘doctrine’ in 1970, stakeholders have exerted increasing influence over companies, whether it be via more conscientious consumers[1], more purpose-driven employees, more aggressive and targeted fiscal systems (corporate tax as a % GDP is up by c. one third since 1970[2]) and/or more informed communities (i.e., voter bases). This has, we believe, increasingly welded together the interests of stakeholders and investors to the point where Boards and management teams that are not proactively addressing the needs of wider stakeholders are likely failing in their fiduciary duties.

As our readers may be aware, we value our companies over a 20-year horizon, a timescale that challenges the imagination, but forces us to consider this transmission of stakeholder value onto a company’s finances. One such example of this is the way in which environmental costs – and in particular those contributing to climate change – are being internalised within companies’ financials, both directly (e.g. via carbon taxes[3]) and indirectly (e.g. via stakeholder action such as changing consumer tastes).

Pricing carbon into earnings and valuation

We have been tracking the carbon footprints[4] of all our portfolios for almost a decade. While the carbon footprint of our portfolios remains well below that of comparable [5], the growing urgency of climate change means that no company is immune from the consequences. This has helped inform both investment decisions (e.g., the divestment of dairy companies) and engagement practices in recent years.

To better understand the potential implications of carbon costs being internalized, we have run some detailed analysis looking at how a carbon tax might impact the profitability and indicative returns of our portfolios.

Step (a) Establish carbon footprint of our holdings: Given the sparsity and disparity of carbon disclosure practices, we use externally acquired data[6] to get a consistent picture of the carbon footprint (measured as tonnes of scope 1 + 2 per US $ million of revenue[7]) of our holdings. Where available, we cross-check this external data with what we know from the companies’ own disclosures.

Step (b) Apply a carbon price: We settled on a figure of USD 75 per tonne, which is a level suggested by the IMF as being required by 2030 to keep global temperatures below 2°C[8]. We multiply the carbon footprint by the carbon price to estimate the absolute cost of carbon tax.

Step (c) Add costs to operating expenses and deduct from margins: We then incorporate carbon costs into each companies’ operating expenses to determine the margin hit[9]. Finally, we incorporated the margin hit into our long-term valuation model (the ‘Arisaig Crystal Ball’, or ACB) to identify the impact on indicative returns. In simple terms, we flex the end-state EBITDA margins in our models by the compression assumed in the previous step. We can then compare the returns of this scenario with our ‘Base’ scenario model to understand the potential impairment.

Figure 1: Process of Applying Carbon Tax to Earnings

What we found

We compared the findings of our holdings with the S&P EM BMI index. We found that our holdings have worse disclosure than the broader market, which is likely due to our skewing to smaller companies and less developed countries. Whilst a challenge in terms of information sourcing, it is a huge opportunity for engaged public equity investors like us to influence positive change.  More encouragingly, we find that our holdings have a lower carbon footprint than their peers within the wider index, which translates into a lower margin compression in the event of a carbon tax. Although this data is far from perfect, it does provide some indication of the relative insulation of these holdings to future carbon taxes.

From a returns perspective, we were also reassured by the modest predicted impact. According to our ACB, the imposition of a USD 75/tCO2e carbon tax on scope 1 and 2 emissions would only hit indicative returns by roughly 3%. While this is not insignificant, we note it assumes a full transmission of the carbon tax on earnings i.e., zero elasticity in pricing or other costs to offset this.

Figure 2: Arisaig Partners Holdings Versus the S&P EM BMI, by Sector (note green indicates better than the benchmark). Source: S&P Global/Trucost, Arisaig Partners analysis. Analysis conducted in May 2022.

Next steps

This analysis provided some reassurance but is not the only way of approaching climate transition risk. As described at the outset, there are various ways in which stakeholder interests can transmit into companies’ finances. Some areas of ongoing work we have identified include:

  • Improving disclosure standards – without clear and accurate data on carbon emissions, stakeholders are unable to appraise the risks and opportunities. We must therefore continue to engage with our companies to improve their measurement and disclosure. We have a target of all our holdings reaching Transition Pathway Level 2 by 2023, which would involve them, among other things, disclosing Scope 1 and 2 emissions.
  • Pushing for ‘Net Zero’ for all of our investments – once carbon emissions have been accurately measured, an action plan can be drawn up. We seek to support all of our holdings to reach ‘net zero’ (i.e. removing all the emissions generated within their operations) by 2050. By successfully pursuing this objective, companies can minimize the risk of carbon pricing.
  • Re-run the analysis as data on emissions and carbon pricing improves – based on progress in recent years, we expect relatively rapid improvements on the data front. Repeating the analysis will keep it relevant.
  • Understanding alternative carbon transmission mechanisms – within many of the sectors and markets we invest in, direct carbon taxes of this magnitude are likely a long way off. However, shifting demand patterns may materialize much sooner. This is hard to capture across all companies in a top-down manner, but with the help of the analysis above, we can zoom into the companies and industries where hit to fundamentals might be the most severe.

[1] e.g. see NYU Stern’s Center for Sustainable Business research – https://www.stern.nyu.edu/experience-stern/faculty-research/latest-research-nyu-stern-center-sustainable-business-and-iri-shows-sustainability-surviving-covid

[2] OECD data to 2020

[3] The pros and cons of using this approach is a blog piece in itself, and perhaps only for the ardent followers

[4] Or more accurately, the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, measured as a carbon equivalent

[5] The greenhouse gas intensity (based on estimated direct + first-tier indirect emissions) of our portfolios are between 66% and 86% lower than comparable indices as of 31 December 2021, according to externally acquired data.

[6] Via Trucost, a subsidiary of S&P

[7] We exclude scope 3 from this specific analysis as we are yet to see enough consistency in disclosure

[8] See – https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/staff-climate-notes/Issues/2021/06/15/Proposal-for-an-International-Carbon-Price-Floor-Among-Large-Emitters-460468; there are a wide range of carbon price estimates out there, with some suggesting a level of $140+ being required to keep emissions in check.

[9] NB. This assumes a full transmission of the carbon tax on earnings – i.e. zero elasticity in pricing or other costs to offset this

Disclaimer:

This material is being furnished for general informational and/or promotional purposes to professional investors only. The views expressed are those of Arisaig Partners and should not be considered as advice or a recommendation to buy, sell or hold a particular investment. They reflect opinion and should not be taken as statements of fact, nor should any reliance be placed on them when making investment decisions. This material does not constitute independent research and is not subject to the protections afforded to independent research.

The statements and views expressed herein are subject to change and may not express current views. Arisaig Partners makes no representation or warranty, express or implied, regarding the accuracy of the assumptions, future financial performance or events. Emerging markets are generally more sensitive to economic and political conditions than developed markets and may be more volatile and less liquid than other investments.

All information is sourced from Arisaig Partners and is current unless otherwise stated. Issued by Arisaig Partners (Asia) Pte. Ltd. Not for public use or distribution. Arisaig Partners (Asia) Pte. Ltd is licensed and regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.

IMPORTANT NOTICE

PLEASE READ THIS IMPORTANT INFORMATION BEFORE PROCEEDING FURTHER.

Terms of Use

These terms and conditions (the “Terms of Use”) set out the terms on which you may make use of this website, and they apply to every page of this website (collectively, the “Site”), whether or not these terms and conditions appear on each individual page. This page contains legal and regulatory notices relevant to the information contained on the Site. By accessing the Site you agree to be bound by the following terms and conditions.

Arisaig Partners (Asia) Pte Ltd (company registration number 199607401H) (“AP Asia”, “us”, “we” or “our”), a member of the Arisaig Group (together the “Arisaig Group”, and each entity within the Arisaig Group, an “Arisaig Group Entity”), reserves the right, at our discretion, to change, modify, add or remove portions of these terms at any time. Therefore, we suggest that you review these pages periodically for changes. By using the Site after we have posted changes to these terms and conditions of use, you are agreeing to be bound by these terms as amended. If you do not agree to these Terms of Use, you should not use this website.

1. About the Site

The Site, www.arisaig.com, is a website operated by AP Asia. AP Asia is registered in Singapore and has its registered office at 6 Lorong Telok #02-01, Singapore 049019. AP Asia is licensed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (the “MAS”) pursuant to the Securities and Futures Act (Cap. 289) of Singapore.

When using this Site, you are responsible for complying with all applicable local, national and international laws and regulations, including those related to data privacy, international communications and exportation of technical or personal data. It may be illegal to download the information contained on the Site in certain jurisdictions and we disclaim all responsibility if you download any information from the Site in breach of any law or regulation of the jurisdiction in which you reside or, if different, in which you download such information.

2. Investment Information

The information contained on this Site is provided for general information and, is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to buy, any security, investment, or financial service or product.

Opinions expressed on this Site are our opinions only and reflect our views only at the time at which such opinions were expressed. Our opinions reflect our views at such time regarding market conditions and other factors, may depend upon assumptions or projections that may not prove to be correct, and are subject to change.

Nothing contained on the Site is intended to constitute investment, legal, tax or accounting advice. You should consult with your own professional advisors for advice on any investment, legal, tax, or accounting issues relating to matters discussed on this Site.

The information contained on this Site is subject to change without notice. For example, the terms of any security, investment, or financial product or service may be changed without notice.

The distribution of the information contained on the Site in certain jurisdictions may be restricted by law and persons who access it are required to inform themselves and to comply with such restrictions. In addition, this Site and its contents have not been prepared for and are not intended for access by the public in the United States. It is your responsibility to be aware of, to obtain all relevant regulatory approvals, licences, verifications and/or registrations under, and to observe all applicable laws and regulations of any relevant jurisdiction in connection with your entrance to this Site.

Decisions based on information contained on this Site are your sole responsibility. In exchange for using this Site, the visitor agrees to indemnify and hold the Arisaig Group and its officers, directors, employees, affiliates, agents, licensors and suppliers harmless against any and all claims, losses, liability, costs and expenses (including but not limited to lawyers’ fees) arising from your use of this Site, from the visitor’s violation of these Terms of Use or from any decisions that the visitor makes based on such information.

3. Risk Factors

Our investment and financial products and services involve substantial risks. You should carefully consider these risks before investing in or purchasing any financial product or service. In particular, you should carefully review and consider all risk disclosures that are provided for any investment or financial products and services. You should evaluate these risks with your professional advisers.

Our services and products, including investment funds managed or sponsored by an Arisaig Group Entity (the “Arisaig Funds“), are available only to those persons who are financially sophisticated, are capable of evaluating the risks and merits of investing in any such products, can bear the economic risk of an investment in such products for an indefinite period, and can afford the loss of their entire investment. The funds referred to in this Site are not authorised or recognisedby the MAS for sale to the public in Singapore.

By making available information on the Site, Arisaig does not represent that any investment vehicle is available or suitable for any particular user. All persons and entities accessing the Site do so on their own initiative and are responsible for compliance with applicable local laws and regulations.

4. Compliance with Certain Restrictions Relating to the Arisaig Funds

The Arisaig Group Entities and the Arisaig Funds may be subject to restrictions under the law of jurisdictions in which any Arisaig Group Entity seeks to provide offering materials, subscription documents and other documents relating to an Arisaig Fund, to make offers to sell shares of an Arisaig Fund, or to solicit offers to buy shares of an Arisaig Fund. As a result, the information on this Site is not intended to be available to any person in any jurisdiction where access to or use of such information would be contrary to law or regulation or which would subject any Arisaig Group Entity or any Arisaig Fund to any registration requirement within such jurisdiction (such persons, “Prohibited Persons“).

The information on this Site is intended to be available only to persons other than Prohibited Persons. Prohibited Persons should not access, act upon or rely on any such information.

EEA: A number of the Arisaig Funds are non-EU AIFs, as defined in Directive 2011/61/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2011 on Alternative Investment Fund Managers (“AIFMD”). The relevant Arisaig Group Entity which is the Alternative Investment Fund Manager (“AIFM”) of such Arisaig Funds is established outside the EU and, as such, is a non-EU AIFM for the purposes of AIFMD.

The content of this Site may only be made available in each member state of the European Economic Area (“EEA Member State”) to the extent that the relevant Arisaig Fund is permitted to be marketed to a professional investor as defined by AIFMD (“Professional Investor”) in the relevant EEA Member State in accordance with AIFMD or may otherwise be lawfully distributed to a Professional Investor in the relevant EEA Member State at the initiative of the investor. Persons who are not Professional Investors should not rely or act on the contents of this site.

United States: The content of this Site is not directed at or intended for persons, individuals or entities that are US persons as defined by Regulation S of the United States Securities Act of 1933 (the “Securities Act“), as amended (“US Persons“) and no securities or services are being offered in the United States or to US Persons.

Neither AP Asia nor Arisaig Partners (Mauritius) Ltd holds itself out as an investment adviser in the United States and does not offer its services to the general public in the United States. The content of this Site is only intended for the account of a US Person who is a qualified purchaser as defined in the United States Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (a “Qualified Purchaser“) and an accredited investor as defined under the Securities Act (an “Accredited Investor“).

Switzerland: The Arisaig Funds have not been registered with the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority and the shares in such Arisaig Funds cannot be distributed in Switzerland to non-qualified investors. Any distribution of the shares in Switzerland may only be made to qualified investors as defined in the Swiss Federal Act on Collective Investment Schemes (“CISA“) and its implementing ordinance (“Qualified Investors”). The content of this Site may only be made available in Switzerland to Qualified Investors.

5. Your use of the Site

By using this website, you have indicated that you accept these Terms of Use, and that you agree to abide by them, and that you are not a Prohibited Person. If you do not agree to these terms and conditions, please refrain from using this website.

Except as otherwise stated in these Terms of Use or as expressly authorized by Arisaig Group in writing, you must NOT use this website (or permit or procure others to use it) as follows:

  1. for any unlawful, improper or illegal purpose or activity;
  2. to communicate or receive information that is obscene, indecent, pornographic, sadistic, cruel, or racist in content, of a sexually explicit or graphic nature, which promotes or incites discrimination, hatred or racism or which might be legally actionable for any reason;
  3. in a manner intended to threaten, harass, or intimidate;
  4. to violate any Arisaig Group entity’s or any third party’s copyright, trademark, proprietary or other intellectual property rights;
  5. to damage Arisaig Group entity’s name or reputation or that of an Arisaig Group entity’s affiliated company or any third parties;
  6. to penetrate Arisaig Group entity’s security measures or other entities’ systems (“hacking”);
  7. to introduce viruses, worms, harmful code and/or Trojan horses onto the internet or into this website or any other entity’s systems and it is your responsibility to ensure that whatever you download or select for your use from this website is free from such items;
  8. to use this Site in any manner that could create impression of affiliation, sponsorship, or endorsement of Arisaig Group;
  9. to post or transmit information that is defamatory, fraudulent or deceptive; and/or
  10. to transmit confidential or proprietary information, except solely at your own risk.

6. Our Liability for Your Use of the Site

Access to the Site is permitted on a temporary basis and we reserve the right to withdraw, restrict or amend the terms of access to the Site without notice. We do not accept any liability if, for any reason, the Site is unavailable at any time or for any period.

Although we seek to assure that the information on this Site is accurate and complete at the time of publication, this Site may contain errors or inaccuracies and no representation or warranty (including implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose), expressed or implied, is made (or accepted) as to its accuracy, completeness, reliability or fitness for any purpose by Arisaig Group or any affiliates or third party providers. The information on this Site is provided “as is”. Under no circumstances, including negligence, will Arisaig Group or any of its affiliates or third party providers be liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, special or consequential loss or damages of any kind arising out of or in connection with access to, reliance on or use of the information on this Site. This paragraph does not limit rights available to you under the laws of your jurisdiction and other rights that may not be waived by contract.

All content on this Site is presented only as of the date published or indicated, and may be superseded by subsequent market events or for other reasons. In addition, you are responsible for setting the cache settings on your browser to ensure you are receiving the most recent data.

This Site may include forward looking statements, including projections of future economic and financial conditions. We do not make any representation, warranty, guaranty or other assurance that any of these forward looking statements will prove to be accurate.

This Site may contain or be linked to other third-party websites as a convenience for visitors. Arisaig Group has no control over such other websites, the contents therein or the products/services offered. Arisaig Group makes no representations or guarantees as to the accuracy, subject matter, timeliness or quality of information on any linked sites and assumes no liability for the content or presentation of such linked sites. Arisaig Group has not and will not review or update information on any linked sites and cautions that any use made of such information is at your own risk.

The internet is not a completely reliable transmission medium and neither we nor any of our affiliates accept any liability for any data transmission errors such as data loss or damage or alteration of any kind or for the security or confidentiality of information transmitted across the internet to or from us or any of our affiliates. Any such transmission of information is entirely at your own risk.

Nothing in these terms of and conditions shall exclude or restrict any duty or liability that we may have to any client under a given regulatory system.

7. Intellectual Property Rights

Unless otherwise expressly noted, all information on this Site are the sole property of AP Asia, which holds and reserves all copyrights, trademarks, service marks, trade names, trade dress and other rights in the same. No material on this Site may be copied, reproduced, republished, uploaded, posted, linked into, transmitted (by electronic means or otherwise), or distributed or used in any way without AP Asia’s written permission. Nothing on the Site should be construed as granting any licence or right in relation to any of our copyrights, trademarks, service marks, trade names, trade dress and other rights.

You must not transmit any virus, “worm”, “Trojan horse”, or other item of a destructive nature to the Site and it is your responsibility to ensure that whatever you download or select for your use from the Site is free from such items.

8. Use of Cookies

The Site uses cookies to record your acceptance of disclaimers displayed on the Site. These cookies are necessary for the functioning of the Site and you cannot opt out of receiving these cookies.

The Site also uses cookies for the purposes of measuring and improving performance of the Site. These cookies allow us to distinguish you from other users and to detect when you visit the Site on two occasions in a 24 hour period. You can opt out of receiving these cookies at any time by adjusting your browser settings.

9. Law and Variation

The Site is established in Singapore by AP Asia in accordance with and shall be governed by, and your browsing in and use of the Site shall be deemed acceptance of, the laws of Singapore. A condition of using the Site is that in the event of any dispute or proceeding you irrevocably submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Singapore Courts and waive any objection to proceedings in such courts on the grounds of venue or on the grounds that the proceedings have been brought in an inconvenient forum.

If any specific term or condition of these Terms of Use is determined by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, void or unenforceable, that determination shall not affect the validity of the remaining provisions of these Terms of Use. Headings used in these Terms of Use are for convenience, are not substantive and shall not be used to interpret or construe any of the provisions contained in these Terms of Use. When used in these Terms of Use the words ‘includes’, and ‘including’ shall be deemed to be followed by the phrase ‘without limitation’.

10. Acceptance of Terms

By accessing the Site beyond this point you represent, warrant and confirm that:

  • You are not a Prohibited Person;
  • You are an Accredited Investor within the meaning of the Securities and Futures Act (Cap 289) of Singapore;
  • If you are in the EEA, you are a Professional Investor;
  • If you are in Switzerland, you are a Qualified Investor;
  • If you are in the United States of America, you are a Qualified Purchaser and an Accredited Investor; and
  • You are not otherwise subject to any restriction prohibiting access to this Site imposed by the laws and regulations of your jurisdiction.

If you are unsure about the meaning of any information provided, please consult your financial or other professional adviser.

If you have any enquiries in relation to our site or the information on it, please contact investorrelations@arisaig.com.