In a previous Insights piece, we described recent updates to our impact measurement and management (IMM) framework. Here we illustrate some of those using the case study of IndiaMart.
IndiaMart Intermesh Ltd (“IndiaMart”) is India’s largest online business-to-business classifieds platform, with over 7 million MSME suppliers using the platform and 1 billion visits per year[1]. IndiaMart’s success is partly due to its 3,000+ strong on-the-ground sales team who visit MSMEs in person, showing them how to optimise their online ‘shopfronts’, which is particularly valuable in the India context where digital literacy is nascent. Our interviews with MSME suppliers suggest that the businesses gain tangible value, with IndiaMart accounting for up to 25 – 30% of revenues.
Theory of change
Five Dimensions of Impact
The next step is a detailed assessment of impact, where we analyse the company from each of the Five Dimensions of Impact[2] (see earlier Insights piece for further detail). Figure 2 provides a high-level summary of this analysis.
Translation into impact scoring
As explained in our previous Insights piece, our updated scorecard considers six categories of impact: Reach, Criticality, Effectiveness, Evidence, Net Impact, and Alignment. In total number, we consider and score 12 impact-related metrics (two under each pillar).
Taking into account all 12 impact-related metrics, the overall Arisaig Impact Score for IndiaMart is 74%. The company scores well across all pillars, but particularly in terms of Alignment (reflecting the strong link between IndiaMart’s financial success and its ability to deliver greater value to MSME customers) and Criticality (reflecting the significant barriers to growth faced by India’s MSMEs, particularly in Tier 2 and smaller cities).
Identifying engagement priorities
A critical component of our contribution to impact as investors is active engagement with companies, with a view to enhancing positive impact, reducing impact risks and improving management of ESG issues. Over the last three years, we have been impressed with the enthusiasm with which the company has responded to our engagements, as well as the progress made to date.